4 Comments
User's avatar
Ancient Threads's avatar

Excellent work tracing the ancient witnesses, particularly the distinction between the Rephaim and the kings of the nations in Greek Isaiah 14:9.

But I'm curious about your conclusion that the righteous still descend into Sheol after Christ's resurrection and ascension.

Hebrews 12:22–23 describes the heavenly Jerusalem and the spirits of the righteous made perfect. Paul desires to depart and be with Christ (Philippians 1:23).

And the risen Lord declares that He now holds the keys of Death and Hades (Revelation 1:18).

Could the resurrection and ascension have fundamentally changed the arrangement you're describing, rather than simply placing Christ within the old one?

Kevin Potter's avatar

Of course it's possible, but I don't believe that's what Scripture describes.

Psalm 139 tells us that the Lord is present in Sheol and always has been, so I don't think it's inserting the risen Jesus into an old system. It's just the continuation of what was always the system.

Consider that Hebrews 12 is addressed to living Jews tempted to return to the sacrificial system. So the writer can't be literally describing the realities of the present. I believe he's shifted into a present tense prophetic register about the eschaton. That's the only way that speaking to living people about coming to the heavenly Jerusalem in the present tense makes sense.

And yes, Jesus holds the keys to death and Hades. But as later chapters (as well as other posts of the NT) make clear, though He has taken all authority from death, Hades, Satan, and the powers, he has not consummated that authority and taken direct control yet, and he won't until His return.

Not to mention that the whole of Scripture speaks to an embodied resurrection here on earth. Nothing anywhere in the whole of Scripture speaks to a disembodied spiritual existence in heaven, with the possible exception of the saints martyred during the tribulation, though even that is open to debate.

So again, is it possible?

Sure.

But I don't think anything in Scripture actually says that, so it would be an argument/inference from lack (or worse, eisegesis) rather than a reading of evidence from Scripture. Especially since the realities of Sheol described in Scripture already explain everything we can point to and have no reason not to still be in force.

James McLaughlin's avatar

Kevin, Craig Blomberg in *Interpreting the Parables* calls Abraham's bosom and Hades two traditional Jewish names for the places of the righteous and wicked dead. If those were stock names Jesus' hearers already knew, He could borrow them without drawing a map of the dead, and the weight of the story falls on the reversal and Abraham's last line about Moses and the prophets. If that's right, how much of the layout in Luke 16 do you think can be treated as description of the place itself?

Kevin Potter's avatar

There are two factors to where I land on that question, James.

First, I don't believe Lazarus and the rich man is a parable. So I take it as authoritative.

Second, say for the sake of argument that I'm wrong and it is a parable. That still leaves one very real fact: There is no parable of Jesus that uses made up geography or set dressing. He grounded all His stories in details that were real. So we still have every reason to accept the descriptions as authoritative.